Skip to Page Content
Search:
Official Seal of the Federal Maritime Comission

 

Activity Log

96-13 -- Holt Cargo Systems, Inc., et al. v. Delaware River Port Authority et al

Last Updated: 6/7/2005 12:24:40 PM
6/5/1996 Received Complaint.
6/5/1996 Served Notice of Filing of Complaint and Assignment.
6/6/1996 Served Notice of Assignment by ALJ Frederick M. Dolan, Jr.
6/12/1996 Notice appeared in Federal Register 61; FR 29755.
6/21/1996 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. for Enlargement of Time within which to File a Response to Complainant's Complaint.
6/21/1996 Received Motion for Extension of Time to Answer or Otherwise Move.
6/24/1996 Served Motions Granted for Enlargement of Time to Answer or Otherwise Move.
7/3/1996 Received Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Motion to Quash Notices of Deposition and to Stay Discovery Until Resolation of Preliminary Motions.
7/5/1996 Received Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.'s Motion to Quash Notices of Deposition and to Stay Discovery.
7/5/1996 Received Motion for Reconsideration or, in the Alternative, for Leave to Appeal Ruling on Motion to Quash Notices of Deposition and to Stay Discovery Until Resolution of Preliminary Motions.
7/8/1996 Served Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.'s Motion to Quash Notices of Deposition and to Stay Discovery Denied.
7/8/1996 Served Motion for Reconsideration or, in the Alternative, for Leave to Appeal Ruling on Motion to Quash Notices of Deposition and to Stay Discovery Until Resolution of Preliminary Motions Denied.
7/9/1996 Received Motion for Correction of Order Denying Respondents Motion for Reconsideration.
8/30/1996 Received Stipulation and Order.
9/3/1996 Served Approval of Stipulation.
9/24/1996 Served Extension of Time Granted Until October 1, 1996.
10/1/1996 Received Affidavit of Earl N. Hansen in Support of Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction and Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction and for Failure to State a Claim upon which Relief can be Granted, or in the Alternative, Motion for More Definite Statement Pursuant to 46 CFR 502.71 and Exhibits.
10/1/1996 Received Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint, or, in the Alternative Motion for a More Definite Statement.
10/2/1996 Received Motion of Respondents Port of Philadelphia and Camden,Inc. and Delaware River Port Authority to Dismiss the Complaint for Lack of Jurisdiction.
10/16/1996 Served Enlargement of Time Granted to Reply to Motions to Dismiss.
10/16/1996 Received Partial Consent Motion for Enlargement of Time in which to File Complainants' Motions to Dismiss Except for the Consent of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.
10/16/1996 Received Partial Consent Motion for Enlargement of Time in which to File Complainants' Opposition to Respondents' Motions to Dismiss, Except for the Consent of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.
10/25/1996 Received Complainants' Omnibus Response to Respondents' Motions to Dismiss.
11/1/1996 Received Subpoenas of: Nissan Motor Corporation, CSX Transportation, Marmara Marine Inc., Chilean Line Inc., Tioga Fruit Terminal, Inc., Maritime Terminal Inc., Weeks Marine (Dredging Company), Independent Pier Company, Delaware River Stevedores, Dependable Distribution Services, Inc., Penn Trucking & Warehousing, Inc., and Horizon Stevedoring.
11/8/1996 Received Delaware River Port Authority Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. and Philadelphia Regional Port Authority Motion for Leave to File Reply to Complainants' Omnibus Response and Motion for Oral Argument.
11/8/1996 Received Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Reply to Complainants' "Omnibus" Response to Motions to Dismiss the Complaint, or, in the Alternative Motion for a More Definite Statement.
11/8/1996 Received Reply Memorandum in Support of the Motion to Dismiss of Respondents DRPA and PPC.
11/8/1996 Received Motion of Delaware River Stevedores for Extension of Time to Move to Quash or Modify Subpoena.
11/12/1996 Motion of Delaware River Stevedores for Extension of Time to Move to Quash or Modify Subpoena Granted.
11/12/1996 Received Motion of Respondents Delaware River Port Authority, Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and Philadelphia Regional Port Authority to Quash Subpoenas Issued by Complainants.
11/12/1996 Received Motion to Quash Filed by Third Party Subpoena Recipients John Brown, Sr., Penn Trucking and Warehousing, Inc. and Horizon Stevedoring.
11/12/1996 Motion to Quash Filed by Third Party Subpoena Recipients Jose A. Diaz, Tioga Fruit Terminal, Inc., and Chilean Line, Inc.
11/14/1996 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. for Extension of Time to Move to Quash or Modify Subpoenas.
11/14/1996 Served Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. for Extension of Time to Move to Quash or Modify Subpoenas Granted.
11/15/1996 Served Motion of Harvey Weiner and Dependable Distribution Services, Inc. for Extension of Time to Move to Quash or Modify Subpoenas Granted.
11/18/1996 Received Complainants' Motion for Sanctions in the Nature of Setting Aside the August 14, 1996, Sublease Agreement Between PRPA and Pasha for Willful and Intentional violation of the ALJ's September 3 Freeze Order.
11/22/1996 Received Motion of Delaware River Stevedores for an Order Quashing Subpoena Requested by Complainants.
11/22/1996 Received Reply of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. to Complainants' Motion for Sanctions.
11/22/1996 Received Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Opposition to Complainants' Motion for Sanctions.
11/22/1996 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. to Quash or Modify Subpoenas.
11/25/1996 Served Motions of Respondents to Dismiss or in the Alternative for a More Definite Statement Denied at this Time Without Prejudice.
11/25/1996 Received Motion to Quash Filed by Non-Party Witnesses Harvey Weiner and Dependable Distribution, Inc.
11/25/1996 Received Transcripts.
12/6/1996 Received Complainants' Omnibus Response to Motions to Quash Subpoenas.
12/9/1996 Served Respondents Granted an Extension of Time Until December 23, 1996, to File Answers.
12/10/1996 Served Motions by Third Party Recipients and Respondents to Quash Subpoenas Denied.
12/16/1996 Received Petition of Delaware River Stevedores for Leave to Appeal the Order Denying Motion to Quash Subpoena or in the Alternative for Reconsideration.
12/16/1996 Received Emergency Motion of Pasta Auto Warehousing for a Stay of Discovery Pending in Camera Inspection of Documents.
12/16/1996 Served Emergency Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. for a Stay of Discovery Pending in Camera Inspection of Documents Denied.
12/23/1996 Received Protective Order of Confidentiality.
12/23/1996 Received Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Answer to Complaint and Countercomplaint.
12/23/1996 Received Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.'s First Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Complainants.
12/23/1996 Received Request for Production of Documents.
12/23/1996 Received Answer of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.
12/23/1996 Received Answer to Complaint of Delaware River Port Authority.
12/23/1996 Received First Request for Documents by PRPA Addressed to Complainants.
12/23/1996 Received Respondent the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc.'s First Request for Production of Documents Addressed to All Complainants.
12/23/1996 Received Respondent the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc.'s First Set of Interrogatories Addressed to All Complainants.
12/23/1996 Received Respondent Delaware River Port Authority's Interrogatories to All Complainants.
12/23/1996 Received Respondent Delaware River Port Authority's First Set of Document Requests to All Complainants.
12/23/1996 Received First Set of Interrogatories by PRPA Addressed to Complainants.
12/23/1996 Received Respondent Port of Philadelphia and Camden's Answer to Complaint.
12/26/1996 Received Appeal of Jose A. Diaz, Tioga Fruit Terminal, Inc. and Chilean Line, Inc. from the Presiding Officer's Denial of Their Motion to Quash Subpoenas Requested by Complainants.
12/26/1996 Received Petition of John Brown, Sr., Penn Warehousing and Distribution, Inc., and Horizon Stevedoring for Leave to Appeal the Order Denying the Motions to Quash Subpoenas or in the Alternative for Reconsideration.
12/31/1996 Received Complainants' Omnibus Response to Certain Non-Parties' Motions for Leave to Appeal the Order Denying Motions to Quash Subpoenas.
1/2/1997 Received Complainants' Notice of Intent to Seek Enforcement of a Valid Subpoena in the United States District Court.
1/2/1997 Received Complainants' Notice of Intent to Seek Enforcement of a Valid Subpoena in the United States District Court.
1/2/1997 Served Notice as to Draft Protective Order and the Issue of "Inside" Counsel.
1/2/1997 Served Petitions for Leave to Appeal the Order Denying Motion to Quash Subpoenas Denied; Petitions for Reconsideration Granted.
1/3/1997 Received Complainants' Omnibus Response to Certain Non-Parties' Motions for Leave to Appeal the Order Denying Motions to Quash Subpoenas.
1/6/1997 Served Request of Complainants for a 20-Day Extension of Time in which to Seek Enforcement of Subpoenas Granted.
1/9/1997 Received Fishbein & Company's Motion to Quash or Modify the
1/9/1997 Received Motion of the Port of Philadelphia and Camden for Extension of Time to Reply to Motions to Quash or Modify Subpoenas.
1/10/1997 Served Request Withdrawn for Reconsideration of the January 6, 1997, Order Granting a 20-day Extension of Time.
1/10/1997 Served Motion of the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. for Extension of Time to Reply to Motions to Quash or Modify Subpoenas Granted.
1/16/1997 Received Complainants' Motion to Quash or Modify, and for a Protective Order, with respect to the subpoenas Issued by the Port of Philadelphia and Camden to Third Parties Fishbein & Company and BDO Seidman.
1/16/1997 Received BDO Seidman's Motion to Quash or Modify the Subpoena Issued by Respondent Port of Philadelphia and Camden and for a Protective Order.
1/22/1997 Received Application to Direct the Filing Under Seal of Respondent the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc.'s Opposition to the Motions of BDO Seidman, Fishbein & Company and Complainants to Quash or Modify Subpoenas, and for a Protective Order. CONFIDENTIAL .
1/23/1997 Served Application to Direct the Filing Under Seal of Respondent the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc.'s Opposition to the Motions of BDO Seidman, Fishbein & Company and Complainants to Quash or Modify Subpoenas, and for a Protective Order, Granted.
2/6/1997 Received Complainants' Motion to Enter Order Adopting the Confidentiality Agreement.
2/12/1997 Served Complainants' Motion for Sanctions in the Nature of an Order Setting Aside the August 14, 1996 Sublease Agreement Between PRPA and Pasha for Willful and Intentional Violation of the September 3 Freeze Order Denied.
2/12/1997 Received Respondent Delaware River Port Authority's Opposition to Complainants' Motion to Enter Order Imposing Confidentiality.
2/13/1997 Served Motions to Quash or modify the Subpoenas Issued by Respondent Port of Philadelphia and Camden and for a Protective Order Granted, Denied.
2/14/1997 Received Memorandum of Non-Party Respondents John Brown, Sr., Penn Warehousing and Distribution and Horizon Stevedoring in Response to the Motion to Enter Order Adopting Confidentiality Agreement and Motion of Pasha Warehousing to take Oral Depositions.
2/19/1997 Received Reply of BDO Seidman in Support of its Motion to Quash or Modify the Subpoena Issued by Respondent Port of Philadelphia and Camden and for a Protective Order.
2/25/1997 Received Complainants' Answer to Counter-Complaint of Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority.
4/4/1997 Received Complainants' Motion for Stay Pending the Preliminary Injunction Hearing in the United States District Court.
4/18/1997 Received Opposition of the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority to Complainants' Motion for Stay.
4/28/1997 Served Protective Agreement of Confidentiality and Order Adopted.
5/5/1997 Received "Attachment A".
5/13/1997 Served Procedural Notice.
5/13/1997 Served Complainants' Request for Stay Pending Completion of the Preliminary Injunction Hearing in the United States District Court Withdrawn and Motion Dismissed.
5/13/1997 Served Notice of Correction.
5/29/1997 Received Discovery Plan and Procedural Schedule.
5/30/1997 Served Discovery Plan and Procedural Schedule.
6/4/1997 Received Complainants' Notice of Intent to Seek Enforcement of a Valid Subpoena in the United States District Court.
6/5/1997 Served Extension of Time.(initial decision due 6/5/98; final decision due 10/5/98).
6/6/1997 Received Motion of Delaware River Stevedores for an Order Declaring Expiration of Subpoena and for Expedited Consideration.
6/9/1997 Received Complainants' Opposition to DRS' Motion for an Order Declaring Expiration of Subpoena by facsimile.
6/10/1997 Received Complainants' Opposition to DRS' Motion for an Order Declaring Expiration of Subpoena.
6/10/1997 Received Complainants' Notices of Intent to Seek Enforcement of a Valid Subpoena in the United States District Court by facsimile.
6/10/1997 Served Motion of Delaware River Stevedores for an Order Declaring Expiration of Subpoena and for Expedited Consideration Denied in Part.
6/11/1997 Received Complainants' Opposition to DRS' Motion for an Order Declaring Expiration of Subpoena by facsimile.
6/11/1997 Received Complainants' Notices of Intent to Seek Enforcement of a Valid Subpoena in the United States District Court.
6/13/1997 Received Complainants' Notices of Intent to Seek Enforcement of a Valid Subpoena in the United States District Court by facsimile.
6/18/1997 Served Motion to Quash Granted.
6/23/1997 Received Motion to Quash Filed by Third Party Subpoena Recipients South Jersey Port Corporation, Al Castagnola, and Joseph Balzano.
6/25/1997 Served Extension of Time to File Reply to Motion to Quash Subpoena Granted.
6/27/1997 Received Motion to Quash of Inchcape Shipping Services to Subpoena of Holt Cargo Systems, Inc. Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45(c)(3).
7/8/1997 Received Complainants' Response to Non Parties South Jersey Port Corporation's, Joseph Balzano's and Al Castagnola's Motion to Quash Subpoena.
7/14/1997 Served Stipulation Approved between Complainants, on the one hand, and, on the other, Horizon Stevedoring, Penn Trucking and Warehousing, Inc., and John Brown, Jr.
7/15/1997 Received Motion to Quash of Norton Lilly International Inc. To Subpoena of Holt Cargo Systems, Inc. Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45(c)(3).
7/17/1997 Served Motions to Quash Granted.
7/22/1997 Received Stipulation Staying Motion of Rice, Unruh, Reynolds Company to Quash Supboena.
7/28/1997 Served Stipulations Regarding Discovery Between Holt and Dependable Services and Harvey Weiner, and Between Holt and Pasha Approved.
8/12/1997 Served Stipulations Between Complainants and J.E. Aspen Shipping Company to Extend Time to Comply with Subpoena duces Tecum Approved.
9/18/1997 Received Second Motion to Quash Filed by Third Party Subpoena Recipient's Al Castagnola and Joseph Balzano.
10/1/1997 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Leave to File an Amended Answer.
10/1/1997 Received Amended Answer of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.
10/17/1997 Served Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Leave to File an Amended Answer Granted.
12/19/1997 Received Plaintiffs' Opposition to the Motion to compel Production of Documents of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.
1/8/1998 Received Motion to Amend the Protective Agreement of Confidentiality and Order Dated April 28, 1997. 
1/8/1998 Served Motion to Amend the Protective Agreement of Confidentiality and Order Dated April 28, 1997, Granted.
3/31/1998 Served Request for New Schedule for Summary Judgment Motions Granted.
4/1/1998 Served Extension of Time. (Initial decision due December 31, 1998; final decision due April 30, 1999).
4/29/1998 Served Postponement of Procedural Schedule.
5/6/1998 Received Motion of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. for Summary Judgment.
5/6/1998 Received Appendix of Exhibits for Motion of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. for Summary Judgment.
5/8/1998 Received Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment of Respondents Delaware River Port Authority and the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. ( CONFIDENTIAL and PUBLIC).
5/8/1998 Received Motion of Philadelphia Regional Port Authority for Partial Summary Judgment on its Countercomplaint and Appendix ( CONFIDENTIAL and PUBLIC).
5/15/1998 Received Unopposed Motion of Complainants for Modification of Due Dates for Filing Replies to Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment and for Filing Responses to Replies.
5/18/1998 Served Unopposed Motion of Complainants for Modification of Due Dates for Filing Replies to Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment and for Filing Responses to Replies Granted.
7/8/1998 Received Motion of Complainants Holt Cargo Systems, Inc. Et al to Amend Paragraph V of the Complaint to Add a Reference to Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act, 1916.
7/8/1998 Received Motion of Complainants' Holt Cargo Systems, Inc. Et al. To Bifurcate the Liability and the Reparation Phases of the Proceeding.
7/8/1998 Received Memorandum of Complainant's Holt Cargo Systems, Inc., Astro Holdings, Inc. And Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc. (1) In Reply to Motion for Summary Judgment and Respondents Delaware River Port Authority, The Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., Philadelphia Regional Port Authority, and Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.; (2) In Reply to Motion for Partial Summary Judgment of Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority on its Countercomplaint; (3) In Support of Complainants' Motion to Amend the Complaint to Add a Reference to Section 10(a)(2) of the 1984 Act and Section 15 of the 1916 Act; and (4) In Support of Complainants' Motion to Bifurcate the Liability and the Reparation Phases of the Proceeding. 4 CONFIDENTIAL VOLUMES
7/17/1998 Received Memorandum of Complainant's Holt Cargo Systems, Inc., Astro Holdings, Inc. And Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc. (1) In Reply to Motion for Summary Judgment and Respondents Delaware River Port Authority, The Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., Philadelphia Regional Port Authority, and Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.; (2) In Reply to Motion for Partial Summary Judgment of Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authoirty on its Countercomplaint; (3) In Support of Complainants' Motion to Amend the Complaint to Add a Reference to Section 10(a)(2) of the 1984 Act and Section 15 of the 1916 Act; and (4) In Support of Complainants' Motion to Bifurcate the Liability and the Reparation Phases of the Proceeding. PUBLIC VERSION
7/23/1998 Received Respondents Response to Complainants' Motion to Bifurcate the Liability and Reparation Phases of the Proceeding.
7/23/1998 Received Respondents Delaware River Port Authority's, the Port of Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Joint Opposition to Complainants' Motion to Amend the Complaint to Add a Reference to Section 10(a)(2) of the 1984 Act and Section 15 of the 1916 Act.
7/23/1998 Received Reply of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc., to Complainants' "Motion to Bifurcate the Liability and the Reparation Phases of the Proceeding".
7/23/1998 Received Reply of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. To complainants' Motion to Amend the Complaint to add a Reference to Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act, 1916.
8/3/1998 Served Motion to Amend Paragraph V of the Complaint to Add a Reference to Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act, 1916, Granted.
8/4/1998 Served Motion of Complainants to Bifurcate the Liability and the Reparation Phases of the Proceeding Granted.
8/7/1998 Received Response of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. To Holt's Reply to Pasha's Motion for Summary Judgment.
8/7/1998 Received Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Reply to Complainants' Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment.
8/7/1998 Received Reply Memorandum of Philadelphia Regional Port Authority in Support of its Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on its Countercomplaint. ( CONFIDENTIAL )
8/7/1998 Received Reply of Respondents Delaware River Port Authority and the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. To Complainants' Memorandum of Law in Response to Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment. ( CONFIDENTIAL )
8/17/1998 Received Motion of Complainants Holt Cargo Systems, Inc., Astro Holdings, Inc., and Holt Hauling & Warehousing Systems, Inc. To Clarify the Procedural Status of Their Section 10(a)(2) Claims.
9/1/1998 Received Reply of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc., to Motion of Complainants "To Clarify the Procedural Status of their Section 10(a)(2) Claims".
9/1/1998 Received Response of Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority to Complainants' Motion to Clarify the Procedural Status of their 10(a)(2) Claims.
9/4/1998 Served Motion of Complainants to Clarify the Procedural Status of their Section 10(a)(2) Claims Granted.
9/11/1998 Received Response of Complainants to September 4, 1998, Order Requesting Views on a Procedural Schedule.
9/16/1998 Served Order as to Discovery on Section 10(a)(2) and Section 15 Issues.
9/21/1998 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc., to Dismiss the Section 10(a)(2) Amendment to the Complaint.
9/21/1998 Received Respondent Port of Philadelphia and Camden's Amended Answer to Complainants' Amended Complaint.
9/21/1998 Received Respondent Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Answer to Amendment to Complaint.
9/21/1998 Received Respondent the Delaware River Port Authority's Amended Answer to Complainants' Amended Complaint.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Complainant Holt Cargo Systems, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Request for Admissions Addressed to Complainant Holt Cargo Systems, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Request for Admissions Addressed to Complainant Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Complainant Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second Set of Request for Production of Documents Addressed to Complainant Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second Set of Request for Production of Documents Addressed to Complainant Holt Cargo Systems, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Request for Admissions Addressed to Complainant Astro Holdings, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second Set of Request for Production of Documents Addressed to Complainant Astro Holdings, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/21/1998 Received Respondents the Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Complainant Astro Holdings, Inc. Relating to Complainants Claims under Section 10(a)(12) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
9/22/1998 Received Reply of Complainants to September 18, 1998 Request of DRPA and PPC to Supplement the Summary Judgment Record.
10/6/1998 Received Complainants' Reply to Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. To Dismiss the Section 10(a)(2) Amendment to the Complaint.
10/20/1998 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Permission to File a Limited Response to Complainant's Reply to its Motion to Dismiss the Section 10(a)(2) Amendment to the Complaint.
10/21/1998 Received Complainants' Answers to Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc.,and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Holt Relating to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
10/23/1998 Received Complainants' Reply in Opposition to Motion of Pasha to Reply to Complainants' Reply to Pasha's Motion to Dismiss.
11/12/1998 Served Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. To Dismiss the Section 10(a)(2) Amendment to the Complaint Denied.
11/19/1998 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Rehearing and Reconsideration of the Administrative Law Judge's Decision Denying its Motion to Dismiss the Section 10(a)(2) Amendment to the Complaint.
11/20/1998 Complainants' Supplemental Joint Answers to Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second and Third Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Holt Relating to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
11/20/1998 Complainants' Holt Cargo Systems, Inc.'s Supplemental Answers to Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second and Third Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Holt Relating to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
11/20/1998 Complainants' Holt Cargo Systems, Inc.'s and Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc.'s Supplemental Joint Answers to Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second and Third Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Holt Relating to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
11/20/1998 Complainants' Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc.'s Supplemental Answers to Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second and Third Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Holt Relating to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
11/20/1998 Complainants' Astro Holdings, Inc.'s Supplemental Answers to Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Second and Third Set of Interrogatories Addressed to Holt Relating to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
11/23/1998 Received Answer of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. to the Complaint as Amended by Order of August 3, 1998 Adding Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 and Section 15 of the Shipping Act of 1916.
11/24/1998 Received Reply of Complainants to Motion for Rehearing and Reconsideration of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.
12/3/1998 Served Extension of Time. (Initial decision due June 30, 1999; final decision due October 28, 1999) .
12/7/1998 Received Joint Motion of Complainants and Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority to Modify the Schedule Applicable to Motions for Summary Judgment Addressed to Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claims.
12/8/1998 Served Joint Motion of Complainants and Respondents The Delaware River Port Authority, the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc., and the Philadelphia Regional Port Authority to Modify the Schedule Applicable to Motions for Summary Judgment Addressed to Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claims Granted.
12/28/1998 Received Complainants' Answers to Supplemental Interrogatories of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. Relating to Section 10(a)(2) and Section 15 Claims.
1/6/1999 Served Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Rehearing and Reconsideration of the Administrative Law Judge's Decision Denying its Motion to Dismiss the Section 1(a)(2) Amendment to the Complaint Denied.
1/13/1999 Served Modification of Procedural Schedule.
1/26/1999 Received Respondents' Delaware River Port Authority, and the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. Motion for Summary Judgment as to Complainants, Claims Under section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984 Based on Allegations of "Conspiracy".
1/26/1999 Received Philadelphia Regional Port Authority's Motion for Summary Judgment on Complainants' section 10(a)(2) Claims as to the Pasha Leases.
1/26/1999 Received Respondents' Delaware River Port Authority, and the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. Motion for Summary Judgment as to Complainants' Claims under section 10(a)(2a) of the Shipping Act of 1984, Related to the Term Sheet. PUBLIC VERSION and CONFIDENTIAL .
1/28/1999 Received Motion of Respondent, Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc., to Compel Complainants, Holt Cargo Systems, Inc., to Respond to Supplemental Interrogatories.
1/28/1999 Received Motion of Respondent, Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc., to Compel Complainants, Holt Cargo Systems, Inc., to Respond to Supplemental Interrogatories.
2/1/1999 Received Complainants' Reply to Pasha's Motion to Compel.
2/17/1999 Received Consent Motion of Complainants Respecting Schedule for the Filing of Complainants' Reply to Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment Addressed to Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claims.
2/18/1999 Served Consent Motion of Complainants Respecting Schedule for the Filing of Complainants' Reply to Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment Addressed to Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claims Granted.
2/22/1999 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Summary Judgment on Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claim re: The Pasha Leases along with an Appendix containing 15 exhibits.
3/10/1999 Received Consent Motion to Suspend Briefing Schedule until April 30, 1999.
3/10/1999 Served Suspension of Procedural Schedule until April 30, 1999.
4/22/1999 Received Unopposed Motion to Suspend Briefing Schedule until July 30, 1999.
7/2/1999 Served Further Notice of Extension of Time. (Initial decision due August 31, 1999; final decision due December 29, 1999).
7/19/1999 Received Unopposed Motion of Complainants and Respondent Port Authorities to Further Suspend the Briefing Schedule Until August 27, 1999.
7/20/1999 Served Unopposed Motion of Complainants and Respondent Port Authorities to Further Suspend the Briefing Schedule Until August 27, 1999, Granted.
8/26/1999 Received Motion of Complainants, Consented to by Respondent Port Authorities, to Suspend Indefinitely the Date for Complainants' Reply to Respondents Delaware River Port Authority and the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. Motions for Summary Judgment (a) As to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act of 1984, Related to the Term Sheet and (b) as to Complainants' Claims Under Section 10(a)(2) of the Shipping Act, 1984 Based on Allegations of Conspiracy.
8/27/1999 Received Complainants Holt Cargo Systems, Inc., Astro Holdings, Inc. and Holt Hauling and Warehousing Systems, Inc. Brief on Reply to Motions for Summary Judgment of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. and Philadelphia Regional Port Authority on Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claims as to the Pasha Leases.
8/27/1999 Received Complainants' Supplemental Appendix.
8/31/1999 Served Further Extension of Time. (Initial decision due August 31, 2000; final decision due December 29, 2000).
9/3/1999 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Reconsideration and Amendment of the Order of the Administrative Law Judge, Date August 3, 1998.
9/10/1999 Received Reply of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. To Complainants' Motion to Suspend Indefinitely the Date for Complainants' Reply to the Motions of Respondents Delaware River Port Authority and the Port of Philadelphia and Camden, Inc. For Summary Judgment on Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claims.
9/15/1999 Served Notice of Prehearing Conference.
9/15/1999 Served Motion of Complainants Held in Abeyance.
9/20/1999 Received Complainants' Reply to Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Reconsideration and Amendment of the Order of the Administrative Law Judge, dated August 3, 1998.
9/24/1999 Received Complainants' and Port Respondents' Joint Stipulation Dismissing with Prejudice Specific Parties and Issues and Settlement Agreement.
9/29/1999 Served Notice of Change of Room for Prehearing Conference to Room 100.
9/30/1999 Received Complainant's Memorandum for Prehearing Conference.
10/15/1999 Received Transcripts of Prehearing Conference.
10/20/1999 Received Response of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. To the Proposed Settlement Agreement, date September 16, 1999.
10/22/1999 Received Complainants' Reply to Pasha's Response to the Settlement Agreement.
10/25/1999 Complainants' Request for Rulings and Procedures to Facilitate Expeditious Resolution of this Docket.
10/26/1999 Served Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Reconsideration and Amendment of the August 3, 1998 Order Denied.
10/26/1999 Served Complainant's and Port Respondents' Joint Stipulation Dismissing with Prejudice Specific Parties and Issues and Modified Settlement Agreement Approved.
10/29/1999 Received Philadelphia Regional Port Authority Response to Complainants' Request for Rulings and Procedures to Facilitate Expeditious Resolution of this Docket.
11/2/1999 Received Motion of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. For Permission to file a Response to Complainants' Reply to its Motion for Summary Judgment on Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claim re the Pasha Leases.
11/3/1999 Served Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel.
11/15/1999 Received Motion of Philadelphia Regional Port Authority for Permission to Respond to Complainants' Reply to Motion for Summary Judgment on Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claim.
11/18/1999 Received Complainants' Opposition to Motions of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. And Philadelphia Regional Port Authority for Leave to Reply to Complainants' Reply to Motions for Summary Judgment Addressed to Section 10(A)(2) Claims.
11/22/1999 Served Motions of Respondents Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. And Philadelphia Regional Port Authority for Permission to File Responses to Complainants' Reply to Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment on Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claim Re the Pasha Leases Granted.
11/22/1999 Served Correction.
12/1/1999 Served Notice Not to Review Dismissal. HTML / Internet Explorer Document Icon
12/6/1999 Received Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law Submitted on behalf of Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc.
12/6/1999 Received Response of Philadelphia Regional Port Authority to Complainants' Reply to Motions for Summary Judgment on Complainants' section 10(a)(2) Claims; PRPA's Proposed Findings of Fact in Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment on Complainant's section 10(a)(2) Claims; and PRPA's Proposed Conclusion of Law in Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment on Complainants' section 10(a)(2) Claims.
12/6/1999 Received Response of Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. To Complainants' Reply to the Motions for Summary Judgment on Complainants' section 10(a)(2) Claim.
12/6/1999 Received Complainants' Proposed Identifications of Fact and Conclusions of Law Relating to the Pending Summary Judgment Motions. ( PUBLIC VERSION )
12/20/1999 Received Pasha's Objections to Complainants' Proposed Identifications of Fact and Conclusions of Law.
12/20/1999 Received Philadelphia Regional Port Authority Response to Complainants' Proposed Identifications of Fact and Conclusions of Law.
12/20/1999 Received Complainants' Reply to the December 6, 1999 Responses of Pasha and PRPA to Complainants August 27, 1999 Reply to Pasha's and PRPA's Motions for Summary Judgment on Complainants' Section 10(a)(2) Claims.
12/20/1999 Received Complainants' Reply to Respondents' Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law.
1/27/2000 Received Complainants' Proposed Identifications of Fact and Conclusions of Law Relating to the Pending Summary Judgment Motions. ( PUBLIC VERSION )
2/9/2000 Served Motions of Philadelphia Regional Port Authority and Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. for Summary Judgment Denied.
2/11/2000 Received Motion for Correction and/or Clarification of Order Denying Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment.
2/28/2000 Received Complainants' Reply to PRPA's Motion for "Correction and/or Clarification".
2/29/2000 Served Ruling Regarding Motion for Correction and/or clarification of Order Denying Respondents' Motions for Summary Judgment.
4/10/2000 Served Notice of Prehearing Conference.
4/18/2000 Received Transcript of Prehearing Conference.
5/19/2000 Received Complainants' Reply to PRPA's May 11, 2000 Request for an Order.
5/24/2000 Served Order Requiring Complainants to File Draft Schedule for Expedited Procedure to Determine Whether FMC has Jurisdiction Over Pasha.
5/26/2000 Served Order Requiring that Each Complainant Individually be Identified with Each Claim or Allegation.
5/31/2000 Served Schedule Adopted for Expedited Procedure to Determine whether the FMC has Jurisdiction Over Pasha.
7/21/2000 Served Postponement of Procedural Schedule.
8/23/2000 Served Notice of Extension of Time. (Initial decision due August 31, 2001; final decision due December 30, 2001).
8/31/2000 Received Joint Motion of Complainants and Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. to Suspend Indefinitely the Schedule Dated May 31, 2000.
9/15/2000 Received Philadelphia Regional Port Authority Opposition to Joint Motion for Stay.
10/4/2000 Served Order Concerning Joint Motion of Complainants and Respondent Pasha Auto Warehousing, Inc. to Suspend Indefinitely the Schedule Dated May 31, 2000.
10/11/2000 Served Modification of Order of October 4, 2000.
11/29/2000 Served Request for Extension of Time Granted.
1/17/2001 Served Procedural Order Terminating Stay and Moving Proceeding Forward.
3/20/2001 Received Complainants’ and Respondents’ Joint Stipulation Dismissing the Complaint herein Without Prejudice.
4/13/2001 Served Complainants' and Respondents' Joint Stipulation to Dismiss the Complaint Without Prejudice Approved on Condition HTML / Internet Explorer Document Icon
5/1/2001 Served Order Affirming ALJ's Approval of Settlement Agreement and Dismissal of Complaint Without Prejudice (By the Commission) HTML / Internet Explorer Document Icon